Why Is Topping A Tree Bad?

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    The procedure of tree topping is a method that can be utilised to increase the size of a tree. This practise can also be referred to as "topping out" or "head-cutting." This method entails chopping off the top of the tree while leaving the trunk intact and trimming the branches from the bottom up. This method can result in an increase of up to fifty percent in the height of the trees, but it calls for the use of heavy equipment and operators with experience in the field.

    Typically, tree topping is conducted on young trees that are not yet strong enough to withstand the weight of environmentally destructive construction equipment such as bulldozers or cranes. These young trees are ideal candidates for having their branches topped. See our list of available arborist services Perth  for your tree removal solutions.

    Trees that have had their tops cut off are at risk of having their structural integrity compromised, experiencing dieback at the site of their new stumps, and even toppling over if another top is cut off at some point during their lifetimes.

    It is essential that people do not cut down trees because trees are an essential component of the ecosystem, and people benefit in many ways from the trees. The process of removing the top branches of a tree in order to encourage it to grow to a greater height is known as "tree topping." It is possible that at first it seems like a good idea because you get more light through your windows; however, there are other ways to accomplish this goal that do not include causing damage to trees!

    Have you ever pondered the purpose behind topping trees? We will discuss the advantages of tree topping and then walk you through the process of topping your own trees. When we have our trees topped, it is for one of two reasons: either they are too close to electricity lines or structures, or the people who own the trees consider that their tree is no longer as appealing and want a change. Topping trees is done for a variety of reasons, and we are going to explore some of those causes today.

    Why Topping Trees Is A Bad Idea

    The practise of capping trees is quite common and may appear to provide a short-term remedy to a problem that is seen to exist. On the other hand, doing so is damaging to the health of the tree and causes issues in the long run. The information that follows will demonstrate why capping trees is a poor decision.

    Topping refers to the practise of cutting tree branches or stubs to lateral branches without considering whether or not they are large enough to take on the role of the terminal branch. There are other synonyms for topping, such as "heading," "tipping," and "rounding over."

    The height of a tree can be lowered by using the topping technique quite frequently. It's possible for a homeowner to feel as though a tree has outgrown its space on their property, or that a particularly tall tree poses a risk that can't be ignored. Topping, on the other hand, is not a practical technique of reducing height, and it most certainly does not remove the possibility of future danger.

    Topping is defined as "the haphazard chopping back of tree branches to stubs or lateral branches that are not large enough to assume the lead position." Topping occurs when a tree is pruned in an unhealthy manner (International Society of Arboriculture). The following are some of the most frequently cited justifications for topping:

    • to prune a tree in order to increase the amount of light that enters a property and to lessen the amount of leaves that fall off the tree each fall.

    Homeowners occasionally have the impression that their trees have grown too large and are concerned that they may present a hazard. Topping a tree is often done in an effort to bring its height down to a more manageable level or to let more light into a home or other building. However, this practise has the ironic effect of having the opposite effect, as it both raises the risk that the tree will fail and causes more of the available light to be blocked out.

    How Topping Creates Hazards

    Following the process of topping, several shoots sprout inside the final 20–25 centimetres of the remaining branches. These new shoots are solely anchored in the surface layers of their new parent branches, whereas normal branch development occurs in a "socket" made up of overlapping layers of wood tissue. As the tree works to reestablish a healthy equilibrium between its root system and its crown, these new shoots develop at a breakneck pace.

    It will take only a few years, but in the end, the tree will be back to the size it was before it was topped. The only difference is that it will have a denser crown, and the young shoots will be more prone to breaking off when there is a high wind.

    Why Topping Creates Physiological Stress

    When you cut down a tree's branches, you also get rid of its leaves, and when you get rid of its leaves, you take away its ability to create food for itself. In addition to this, the tree will experience extreme physiological stress as a result of the loss of its ability to produce food.

    • When a tree is under stress, it is more susceptible to assault from various diseases and insects. Pests are rarely solely responsible for the demise of a tree; but, if the tree is already in a compromised condition, its demise may be a consequence of the weakened condition.
    • Large wounds that are left open after pruning leave the wood vulnerable to rot, and the tree may not have sufficient resources to "defend" the wounds chemically against an invasion by fungi.

    The leaf-bearing crown of a tree can lose anywhere from 50 to 100 percent of its volume when it is topped. A tree's leaves serve as its food production facilities. Therefore, removing them can temporarily deprive a tree of its food supply and set off a number of different survival processes.

    The dormant bugs are awoken, which results in the quick growth of many shoots directly below each cut. As a direct consequence of this, it is imperative that the tree quickly produce a fresh set of leaves. If a tree does not have the stored energy reserves to do so, it will suffer severe weakening and eventually die if it is unable to do so. When a tree is topped, anywhere from 50 to one hundred percent of the crown that bears leaves is cut away. Because leaves are a tree's primary source of nutrition, the loss of this food supply can result in the tree becoming momentarily malnourished.

    As a form of self-defense, the sapling that is being starved will respond by swiftly sending forth many shoots from dormant buds located below each incision. This behaviour is the tree's survival mechanism, and it is designed to produce a new flush of leaves as quickly as possible. In addition, if the tree does not have adequate stored energy reserves to react in this manner, it may suffer severe damage, which may even result in the tree's death before its natural time. leaf-bearing

    Topping Causes Decay


    When doing pruning, the cut should ideally be made just beyond the branch collar at the place where the branch attaches to the parent branch. The tree possesses the biological components necessary to recover itself from such an injury, given that the tree is in sufficient good health and the wound is not excessive in size.

    When cuts are made along the length of a limb, between lateral branches, stubs with wounds that the tree may not be able to repair are produced. As a direct consequence of this, the exposed wood tissues start to rot. The correct place to make a cut during pruning is immediately below the branch collar, at the point where the branch attaches. The tree possesses the biological components necessary to recover itself from such an injury, given that the tree is in sufficient good health and the wound is not excessive in size.

    When cuts are done along a limb between lateral branches, the tree is left with stubs that have wounds that it may not be able to heal. When wood is exposed like this, the wood tissues start to rot. In a typical situation, a tree will "wall off" or compartmentalise the rotting tissues; however, very few trees are able to defend themselves against the multiple serious wounds that are created by topping. The decay organisms are provided with an unimpeded route via which they can travel down through the branches.

    The rotting tissues of a tree will typically "wall off" or become compartmentalised while the tree is healthy. But very few trees are able to protect themselves against the several serious wounds that topping causes. The decay organisms are provided with an unimpeded route via which they can travel down through the branches.

    The volume of money that is given to the contractor for performing the operation is included in the preliminary cost of topping a tree. The following are some examples of the subsequent costs:

    • If the tree is able to make it through the next few years, it will either need to be pruned once more or the storm damage that was caused by the failure of its shoots will need to be cleaned up.
    • In the event that the tree passes away, it will need to be cut down and removed.
    • Trees that have been topped are more likely to break and may pose a danger. Because topping is not deemed to be an authorised form of pruning, any damage caused by the failure of a limb on a topped tree could result in a finding of negligence in a court of law.
    • Damaged and perhaps sick trees are a financial concern. Healthy trees that have been carefully maintained can add anywhere from 5 to 18 percent to the value of a property.

    Topping Can Lead To Unacceptable Risk

    It is a very costly process for the tree to maintain the survival mechanism that results in the production of many shoots below each topping cut in a tree. These shoots originate from buds that are located close to the surface of the older branches. These young shoots are rooted only in the outermost layers of the parent branches, which results in a weak attachment. This is in contrast to the development of regular branches, which takes place in a socket formed by overlapping wood tissues.

    The new shoots develop at a rapid rate, reaching a height of up to 20 feet in just one year. Unfortunately, the shoots are prone to breaking, and this tendency is exacerbated when the weather is windy or icy. Although lowering the height was supposed to make the situation safer, the danger of limb failure has actually increased as a result of the change.

    Alternatives To Topping

    There are circumstances in which it is necessary to prune a tree in order to bring it into compliance with prevailing utility clearance requirements. There are certain methods that are suggested for carrying out do. The first step is to prune back smaller branches all the way to where they first emerged. Second, if a larger limb needs to be trimmed back, the trimming should be done so that it ends at a lateral branch that is substantial enough to take on the job of the terminal branch. Planning for a  tree lopping, pruning, wood chipping, mulching, palm removing & stump grinding? At Tree Amigos, you can find high quality and affordable arborist services for your needs.

    This technique for cutting back branches contributes to the tree's natural appearance being preserved. On the other hand, there are situations in which the best option is to cut down the tree and replace it with a species that is more suited to the location.

    Consult with or employ an experienced arborist if you ever find yourself in a situation where it is required to make changes to the size of a tree's height or spread. An arborist will evaluate your trees and decide which types of trimming are required to preserve or improve the trees' health as well as their appearance and their level of safety.

    Climbing spikes that are harmful to trees are not allowed to be used by certified or professional arborists unless the tree is being removed entirely. They do not mention topping as a service in their yellow pages ad, and they will never recommend it to you as a solution because it is not a service that they offer.

    Tree Topping – What You Don’t Know Is Killing Your Trees

    Trees continue to have their tops lopped off without any regard for whether or not they will survive. Trees that have been abused for many years and are now twisted and dying can be found everywhere. In particular, referring to the mistaken practise of topping trees, which is what They have in mind. This practise, which goes by a variety of names, including pollarding, stubbing, dehorning, heading, and a few others, has reached a crisis level on a national level over the past decade.

    The practise of topping trees is widely regarded as the most dangerous form of tree cutting. As a matter of fact, it is considered to be such a heinous crime against nature that the primary focus of an organization's activities over the past two decades has been to put an end to this "torture and mutilation."

    Plant Amnesty was established in 1987 in the city of Seattle, Washington, by Cass Turnbull. This charitable organisation seeks to educate the general public about "Crimes Against Nature" that are being committed right here in our own back yards by employing a novel strategy that combines humour with a healthy dose of controversy. In spite of the fact that more than 20 years of verbal and written information has been disseminated, the technique is still widely used.

    According to the International Society of Arboriculture, the most common reason given for topping is to lower the size of a tree, either because it has become too huge for the land or because there is a concern that it may pose a risk. Surprisingly, topping is not a workable strategy for minimising size or the risk of injury.

    Topping Does Not Control Size

    When new shoots begin to grow, the plant does so quickly in an effort to replace its food-making factory as quickly as possible, sending up a large number of "water sprouts." These new shoots can develop up to 6 metres (about 20 feet) in just one year for some species. As a direct consequence of this, trees will regrow very quickly, and their rate of expansion won't begin to slow until they are roughly the same size as before. It usually only takes a few years for anything like that to take place.

    Topping Does Not Make Trees Safer

    The new growth that quickly emerges from dormant buds just below each cut is only firmly rooted in the most superficial layers of the parent branch. These feeble attachments will never have the structural integrity of the original branch and can easily break off, even many years later when they are enormous and heavy due to the fact that they will never achieve it.

    When proper pruning cuts are done, healthy trees are genetically designed to repair the wound. These cuts should be made just beyond a branch collar at the place where the branch attaches to the trunk. Incorrect cuts made from stubs or tops do not heal as quickly and in some cases may never be able to close. The exposed wood leads to deterioration, ports of entrance, and pathways that allow creatures that cause damage, such as pests, illnesses, and destructive organisms, to migrate into and through the branches.

    Topping Is Expensive

    It is important to keep in mind that when a tree is topped, it quickly grows back with branches that is much thinner and weaker. As a result, using toppings as a means of reducing portion size is a vicious cycle. With each cycle, the conditions become significantly more difficult to deal with. Each cut results in the sprouting of several new branches. When the tree finally succumbs to the consequences of the accumulated stress and damage, its removal will most certainly cost even more money. This will occur at some point in the future.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Topping a tree means removing the uppermost part of the tree, including the main trunk and branches. This pruning is typically done to reduce the tree's size or shape it into a certain desired form. However, topping a tree can also be harmful to its health. 

    Topping can damage the tree's bark and leave it vulnerable to disease and pests when done improperly. In addition, topping can encourage new growth that is weak and prone to breakage. As a result, it is important to consult with a certified arborist before topping any trees on your property.

    Tree topping is the act of removing the uppermost branches of a tree. While it may seem like a good way to keep a tree under control, it can do more harm than good. Tree topping leaves the tree vulnerable to disease and pests, and it can also cause the tree to produce new growth that is weak and poorly structured.

    In addition, tree topping can increase the risk of wind damage, as the upper branches are no longer there to act as a stabilising force. As a result, it is generally best to avoid tree topping altogether. However, if you are concerned about the size or shape of your tree, consult with a certified arborist who can offer guidance on how to trim your tree safely.

    When you remove the top of trees, it's called topping. Tree topping is a popular technique used to control the size and shape of trees.

    It involves cutting off the tree's main stem, or leaders, which forces the tree to produce new growth. This new growth is typically shorter and more compact than the original leaders, resulting in a smaller tree. 

    While topping can effectively achieve your desired results, it's important to be aware of the potential risks involved. Topping can cause long-term damage to trees, including stunted growth, weak and deformed branches, and an increased risk of pest infestation and disease. As a result, it's important to consult with a qualified arborist before undertaking any tree topping projects.

    Topping a tree is removing the entire upper canopy of a tree, leaving only a bare trunk. This is often done to relieve the branches' weight or reduce the tree's height.

    Thinning, on the other hand, is the process of selectively removing individual branches from a tree. This is often done to improve the tree's shape or increase air and light circulation. 

    Both topping and thinning can be beneficial to a tree if done correctly; however, they can also cause harm if not done properly. When done correctly, topping and thinning can help improve a tree's health and appearance; when done improperly, they can damage the tree and make it more susceptible to disease and injury.

    Tree topping is the practice of cutting off the uppermost branches of a tree. This can be done for various reasons, including reducing the tree's height, thinning out the foliage, or clearing away dead branches. 

    Although tree topping may seem like a straightforward way to achieve these objectives, it can do more harm than good. Topping removes large amounts of foliage, which can put stress on the tree and make it more susceptible to pests and disease.

    It also encourages the growth of weak, unstable branches more likely to break in storms. As a result, arborists generally discourage tree topping, which should be avoided if possible.

    Tree Topping – 4 Reasons Why You Should NOT Top Trees 


    Topping trees is an overused and unsophisticated form of pruning in which the arborist chops all of the major branches to the point where they are left with blunt ends and there are no secondary branches left to take over as the dominant form of the tree. Topping is not a suitable way of pruning and should be applied infrequently or not at all if at all.

    Despite this, it is extremely common among tree services that lack experience. Topping trees not only decreases the aesthetic value of the tree as a whole but also has major detrimental effects on the tree's ability to maintain its structural integrity. The practise of topping trees is detrimental to their health and should be avoided for the following four reasons.

    Counter Productive Healthy Tree Vs Topped Tree

    To "lower the risk of towering, mature trees," topping is most frequently requested by the homeowner or recommended by an unskilled tree care specialist. Topping can also be done for aesthetic purposes. This approach of pruning, however, is ineffective because the majority of older trees have large root systems that are well-equipped to retain their stability.

    Structural Failure

    The unexpected removal of a substantial amount of the tree's foliage places a strain on the plant's capacity to provide sufficient nutrition for its own roots, branches, and trunk. Topping a tree results in a significant reduction in the overall number of leaves on the tree, which in turn restricts the amount of water and energy that the Topped Tree tree is able to produce.

    In addition to that, topping is very crucial for the overall health of the trees. For instance, elm trees (genus Ulmus) can drink anywhere from 250 to 300 gallons of water every single day. Therefore, topping an elm tree would only increase the likelihood of branch failure since the tree would not be able to release enough water to keep the limbs at a stable weight. This would cause the likelihood of branch failure to grow. If you're looking for tree removal services, you’re in the right place! Check Tree Amigos!


    In most cases, topping will result in incorrect wounds that will not heal in the correct manner. The tree is able to organically mend itself through a process known as compartmentalisation when the appropriate cuts are made. The tree will produce protective layers over the part that is rotting or damaged, such as a pruning cut, at this point.

    On the other hand, topping a tree prevents the natural healing process from taking place, so it should be avoided if possible. Because of this, it is possible for diseases and decay to spread throughout the tree. This is analogous to how an open wound on a person's skin permits bacteria to enter the body.

    Higher Cost To Maintain

    Topping a tree causes it to produce water sprouts at a rate that is three times faster than its typical growth rate. This results in the need for a much more rigors pruning schedule and contributes to the fact that the homeowner will have to pay more to maintain the tree than they would have to if the tree had been pruned properly. If a tree is pruned properly, it should only need to have its branches cut once every two to five years under normal circumstances. Of course, the rate at which each individual tree grows might vary, but in general, this is the case.

    Scroll to Top